“Why was this deleted” is staple at CiF Watch, as it often demonstrates CiF’s biased moderation process, and so anyone who reads this blog is all too familiar with the images along the lines of the following:
But, sometimes, the Guardians are evidently so infuriated by a comment that it disappears completely, without any visual trace whatsoever that the heterodox thought was ever expressed.
Here’s a cheeky comment by HushedSilence in the thread beneath the CiF piece (Bahrain will not digress from reform, Hamad bin Isa al-Khalifa, the King of Bahrain, June 1):
And, then:
Well, this is where we’d typically place a snapshot of the “this comment was removed…”, except that, well, all traces of the comment completely disappeared. Even CW can’t take a snapshot of empty space.
However, the episode led me to thinking:
The Soviet government used to use crude techniques to change many of the photographs which had been taken after the October 1917 revolution to give the illusion that Trotsky had only a minimal role and did not share a close relationship with Lenin. As you can see in the photo below, Trotsky is clearly standing next to Lenin in the first photograph, but is then removed in the second (and replaced by a hazy dark patch where nothing is clearly visible, giving an indication of the poor quality of Soviet alteration techniques)
Not that we’re comparing the Guardian to the Soviet Union (cough…Seumas…cough….Milne).









8 comments
Comments feed for this article
June 1, 2011 at 1:47 pm
Yohoho
I wonder what Greg Philo would think of that bias?
June 1, 2011 at 2:09 pm
censorship is free
More proof,(ie,fact based evidence),that cif is utterly uninterested in free debate or comment,and completely interested in the most blatant censorship.
Keep up the good work cifwatch,although cif,like many of the fascists and fascist appeasers it gives platform to,has a complete lack of shame.
June 1, 2011 at 2:46 pm
Yohoho
Censorship is free, how can fascists etc feel shame when they are so convinced of their own rectitude? No, it would take a much less extreme thinking style for them even to apprehend that they may be wrong.
Their current thinking style is more in the style of that which gave rise to the Nuremberg laws.
June 2, 2011 at 1:39 am
Richard
Yes, this is a common occurrence. I blogged about my experience with it in a blogpost titled “The Guardian UK as Big Brother, an analogy,” back in 2009. Check it out by clicking on the link.
June 2, 2011 at 2:27 am
Hushedsilence
Mods just aren’t what they used to be. They cleansed my comment and Usini’s indignant response to it after some comment (which they cleansed as well) but they left this dirty spot.
AgeOfLibra
1 June 2011 5:01PM
Oh come on HushedSilence its great when pretty much all of us can link arms and agree about something.
September 29, 2011 at 5:59 pm
LUJohn
Toro Rosso STR4 на информационном портале о спорте. Самые интересные новости мирового спорта!
October 19, 2011 at 8:51 pm
VGNeil
независимый на информационном сайте о культуре и искусстве. С нами вы всегда в курсе всех новостей культуры, дизайна и шоу-бизнеса.
January 8, 2012 at 9:53 am
viebal
Доброго форумчане.
Короче, увидел
туб
viebal.ru с экслюзивной подборкой
порно роликов. Делюсь с удовольствием здесь.
Смело заходите и бесплатно смотрите, портал обновляется каждый день,
очень много эксклюзивного видео, которое нигде не встретишь.
Если есть еще прикольные видео порталы – постите тут – буду благодарен, посмотрим и (подрочим:)