There is so much political pathos to dissect in Gary Younge’s diatribe against Israel yesterday (see our replies here and here) but one of the most telling themes in his myopic broadside worth exploring was his implicit accusation that Israel was a “white country” which discriminates against it’s darker skinned residents – particularly evident in this passage:
“At the [border] crossing into Nazareth, only brown-skinned people had their passports held.”
As I noted in the previous post, the journalistic malfeasance of implying that Israeli border security discriminates based on the skin color of those wishing to enter the country – and not rigorous screening procedure based on the state’s long history of terrorists attempting to infiltrate its borders – based solely on a couple of hours of observation is not worthy of a college rag yet alone the website of a major UK newspaper.
But, beyond the particulars of Younge’s assertion, the implicit argument is even more morally reckless.
Younge seems to see the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict through the remarkably skewed view of a “white” Jewish state oppressing “people of color” – Palestinians/Arabs.
I’m not sure if Younge spent any time in our country but it’s highly unlikely that, if he did, he considered the ample visual evidence while walking down the streets in cities such as Jerusalem or Tel Aviv which would have contradicted his hypothesis, and demonstrated that the average Israeli is darker than most citizens in dozens of liberal European capitals.
As I’ve noted elsewhere, the ethnic, national, and racial diversity in Israel is a legacy of the cultural diversity and far-flung nature of the Jewish Diaspora: it is said that Jews have come to modern Israel from 103 countries, speaking more than 70 different languages upon arriving on her shores.
Indeed, as I noted yesterday, in addition to the 25% of Israeli citizens who aren’t Jewish, about half of Israel’s Jewish population are Jews of color – that is, Jews whose ancestry originates from the Middle East, North Africa, Ethiopia, South America, India, the Caucasus and elsewhere.
The following photos – attesting to Israel’s remarkable racial and ethnic diversity - won’t be at all surprising to anyone who calls Israel home, or has spent any time here.











52 comments
Comments feed for this article
April 26, 2011 at 12:28 pm
Hawkeye
@profil97
In fairness to Younge, what he looks like is irrelevant and should not be used as a stick to beat him as it smacks of the same bigotry we are accusing him of.
April 26, 2011 at 12:33 pm
profil97
hawkeye,
Totally disagree with your assessemnt. I commented on his quote unquote corpulence. Did not say a word about his skin color.
No bigotry displayed whatsoever.
April 26, 2011 at 1:11 pm
profil97
Indiscreet Conversations (Barack Obama, Presidential Election 2008, Politics)
Jesse Jackson’s gaffe demonstrates that the days of being able to think out loud are over.
Gary Younge
http://www.thenation.com/section/Hymietown
He refers to that brazen bigoted remark as being merely a gaffe.
Apparently, in Gary Younge’s warped mind, Jackson is only guilty of inadvertently uttering private thoughts in public and nothing more.
April 26, 2011 at 1:17 pm
ziontruth
“Which is racism in reverse.”
No, it’s not reverse racism, just racism. The only difference is the object of hatred.
Furthermore, the Leftist concept of “racism” has nothing to do with race. It is simply a pronouncement of anathema against anyone they hate. With today’s Left, you can be an honorary “person of color” despite being white, as is the case with the Bosnian Muslims, and you can be a de jure “white man” despite having a dark tone of skin, as is the case with black Tea Party members and any brown-skinned Jew happening to sincerely believe in the rightness and justice of the Zionist project.
April 26, 2011 at 1:32 pm
pretzelberg
A ridiculous comment from Younge that makes him look either shamelessly ignorant or malicious for the sake of it. And the Disney intro analogy is simply bizarre.
April 26, 2011 at 1:45 pm
profil97
“Furthermore, the Leftist concept of “racism” has nothing to do with race… sincerely believe in the rightness and justice of the Zionist project”
I for one would not reduce the whole thing to left-wing politics. It goes much deeper than that.
Gary Younge is all about being black and African, first and foremost. The rest is secondary in his color-coded world. He plays the race card like others play baseball on weekends.
With all due respect, Israel today is an established nation-state, not some Zionist project circa 1901.
Thanks for your comment.
April 26, 2011 at 2:20 pm
ziontruth
profil97,
“I for one would not reduce the whole thing to left-wing politics. It goes much deeper than that.”
I agree, but it’s a hallmark of present-day left-wing politics. (I say “present-day” because the pre-Marxist Old Left wasn’t like this.)
“With all due respect, Israel today is an established nation-state, not some Zionist project circa 1901.”
I know that. You know that. All Zionists know that. But Progressives like Younge don’t accept that. One of the ironies of being of Progressive (hard-left really) political persuasion is that you get to view the world as if this were still 1901. They are absolutely sold on the idea that Zionism is a project and nothing more, an episode as transient as the French episode in Algeria (God forbid). I was echoing their line of thinking; I probably should have put that expression in quotation marks.
Thank you too.
April 26, 2011 at 2:46 pm
conchovor
‘Here is a suggestion, instead of patronizing fast food eateries ten times a day, that fatso would be better off donating his Guardian earned dough to hungry kids, say, in Jamaica.’
Why the reference to Jamaica? Cause you assume he comes from there?
Dodgy racist crap. Shut the f— up.
April 26, 2011 at 2:49 pm
conchovor
And Younge is an idiot. Whose ethnicity and girth are irrelevant.
April 26, 2011 at 2:50 pm
conchovor
Famously Mira Awad is lighter than Achinoam Nini.
April 26, 2011 at 2:54 pm
SerJew
Yet another fact that exasperates those professional Jew-haters: no only is Israel a successful, advanced and proud liberal democracy; it´s probably more multicultural/multiethnic than the EU members, not to mention the muslim paradises.
April 26, 2011 at 3:14 pm
cba
SerJew, you make an excellent point, and one that Israelis–especially those still craving acceptance/approval from the lefties of the world–would do well to internalize: It’s not Israel’s sins they hate, but its virtues.
April 26, 2011 at 3:45 pm
Groovy Times
SerJew, I had a similar conversation with my partner – who is Nigerian, when we stood at Netanya train station the summer before last, observing the rich mix of people who make up the demographic of Israel, from black to white and many shades in between, including women comfortable sporting their Muslim head-scarves deep in the heart of the ‘Zionist entity’. “And this is what the anti-Zionists call an apartheid state”, I said.
If Younge went to Israel, he has embellished reality to fit the prejudices of his readership.
April 26, 2011 at 4:54 pm
Groovy Times
Adam Levick, this should be the future of Israeli hasbara; black Israelis confronting the prejudices of their European critics. “Israel a colonial apartheid state? F*ck you, you white ‘liberal’ bigot, you’re no different from your racist grandparents!” Take that sanctimonious rug from right under their feet.
April 26, 2011 at 5:07 pm
pretzelberg
@ SerJew
Younge is an ignorant anti-Israel jock. But spare use the “professional Jew-hater” bullshit.
April 26, 2011 at 5:16 pm
SerJew
“Younge is an ignorant anti-Israel jock. But spare use the “professional Jew-hater” bullshit.” pretzle
Oh, Church-lady is back! With that same sanctimonious preaching style.
Listen, a piece of advice for you, pal: stick your PC-crap where the sun won´t shine, ´kay?
Ah, you forgot your pathetic trade-mark little slogan “shame on you”. SHAME ON YOU for that.
April 26, 2011 at 5:17 pm
Abban Aziz
@ Pretzel
He is. Call a spade a spade. These days it is impolite to accuse antisemites of being antisemites because they pull the “OH MAN CRITICISM OF ISRAEL IS NOT ANTISEMITISM!11!! You are trying to censor me!!!
He is an antisemitic bigoted troll. Period. There is not one fact in his article. He is a joker. My account was disabled because I criticized his views.
April 26, 2011 at 5:24 pm
SerJew
“SerJew, you make an excellent point, and one that Israelis–especially those still craving acceptance/approval from the lefties of the world” cba
Exactly, just like our own pretzl-”Church-Lady”-berg.
It must be sad to live in this state of mental servitude. On the other had, it´s easy not having to think for oneself and just to shout “shame on you” when you don´t have anything intelligent to say.
April 26, 2011 at 5:33 pm
Adam Levick
Please note: Garry Younge’s physical characteristics are completely irrelevant, and represent an ad hominem attack. Any references made, explicitly or implicitly, to such traits will be deleted.
April 26, 2011 at 5:42 pm
pretzelberg
Abban Aziz
He is an antisemitic bigoted troll.
This website is already suffering under a two-digit BTL poster IQ without the likes of you and SerJew contributing.
The actual articles deserve a better class of respondent.
April 26, 2011 at 6:03 pm
SerJew
“This website is already suffering under a two-digit BTL poster IQ without the likes of you and SerJew contributing.” Church-lady
Are you trying to silence people´s opinions?!? SHAME ON YOU, pretzlie.
“The actual articles deserve a better class of respondent.”
Thus ordered comrade pretzlovitch, People´s High Commissar for Sanctimonious Speechying and Preservation of Politically Correct Inanities.
April 26, 2011 at 6:05 pm
Hoi Polloi
“Please note: Garry Younge’s physical characteristics are completely irrelevant, and represent an ad hominem attack.”
It should also work the other way. Thus, for example, Linda Grant’s great charm and natural beauty should not deter us from criticising her vigorously.
April 26, 2011 at 6:09 pm
SerJew
“Thus, for example, Linda Grant’s great charm and natural beauty should not deter us from criticising her vigorously.” Hoi Polloi
Same with Kate Middleton, future queen of all things british. As for Williams, he´s just nazi scum.
April 26, 2011 at 6:29 pm
pretzelberg
Quite why Ser “I hate non-Jews” Jew is allowed to comment on a site allegedly dedicated to challenging bigotry is beyond me.
And I see Hoi Polloi is likewise bringing down the standard of debate to something below juvenile.
As I’ve said before: comment by comment, the BTL material here makes CiF looks positively enlightened.
April 26, 2011 at 6:34 pm
pretzelberg
SerJew 6:09 pm
Reminds me of those sad posters on Cif who clearly have no friends in real life.
Rowan Williams or Richard Williamson. They’re all the same, right?
April 26, 2011 at 6:35 pm
SerJew
“…BTL material here makes CiF looks positively enlightened.” Church-lady
Man, you´ve been complaining about that in your oh-so-deep-”shameonyou”-type of repeatedly.
So, why don´t you quit whinning about other people´s views, take an adult attitude, and move your comments to CiF? You´ll fit just perfectly there.
April 26, 2011 at 6:38 pm
SerJew
“Reminds me of those sad posters on Cif who clearly have no friends in real life” church-lady
Projection?
Again, buddy, if you admire so much Cif, why don´t you just quit whinning and go post there? They´ll love to hear your in-depth comments, such as
the now-classic “SHAME ON YOU”.
April 26, 2011 at 6:56 pm
SerJew
“Quite why Ser “I hate non-Jews” Jew is allowed to comment on a site allegedly dedicated to challenging bigotry is beyond me.” pretzlie
No, no, darling. I just find *your* type of PC-style pseudo-moralizing great laughing material.
I noticed you can´t stop your inner little commissar mentality to surface, eh? Well, that´s part of your leftist servile mentality: can´t tolerate dissent, has a bent on preaching and silencing others, think yourself above other people, displays a self-serving self-delusional moral immaculacy, limited sense of humor and inability to grasp sarcasm. Truly sad.
And now the talk about IQ…Good grief.
April 26, 2011 at 7:10 pm
pretzelberg
SerJew
Again, buddy …
What kind of talk is that?
if you admire so much Cif …
My comment above was hardly positive towards CiF.
I pity people like you. Why? Because you have yet to free yourself of needless hate and bigotry.
April 26, 2011 at 7:12 pm
pretzelberg
SerJew
I noticed you can´t stop your inner little commissar mentality to surface, eh? Well, that´s part of your leftist servile mentality: can´t tolerate dissent
Hilarious!
“can´t tolerate dissent” says Mr supreme irrational bigot.
April 26, 2011 at 7:17 pm
SerJew
“I pity people like you. Why? Because you have yet to free yourself of needless hate and bigotry” pretzlie
LOL. Man, you are so full of yourself that you can´t even see the amount of projection in the line above. And so magnanimous and condescending.
Really funny.
Because it´s *YOU* that needs to free yourself from your PC- mental cage. You are the one that seems full of hate, intolerant to dissent and wanting to silence people. This is mental servility at its worst.
Grow up! And cheer up too. Relax. Go watch a special on the royal wedding. Or go self-flagellate about Chernobyl.
April 26, 2011 at 7:22 pm
SerJew
“can´t tolerate dissent” says Mr supreme irrational bigot.” pretzlie
More projection! Bring more, bring more.
Meanwhile, tell us about your experience of revelation and redemption, when you “freed yourself of needless hate and bigotry” (except of course, against people that don´t thin like yourself).
When did you get your superior knowledge of things, your gnosis, and then decided to spread the gospel like a church-lady treating little toddlers?
April 26, 2011 at 7:24 pm
pretzelberg
SerJew
Go watch a special on the royal wedding. Or go self-flagellate about Chernobyl.
Now you’re getting seriously delusional.
Man, you are so full of yourself that you can´t even see …
Youtube-standard intellect.
I take issue with a lot – but not all – of what this site is about. You are simply an embarrassment to CiFW.
April 26, 2011 at 7:26 pm
pretzelberg
SerJew
and then decided to spread the gospel like a church-lady treating little toddlers?
Bizarre and nonsensical.
April 26, 2011 at 7:34 pm
SerJew
“I take issue with a lot – but not all – of what this site is about. You are simply an embarrassment to CiFW.” church-lady
Always sermonizing… Can´t you do anything else?! You display the prototypical leftist commissar mentality, exemplifying to perfection why the left reached complete moral bankruptcy.
You are an embarrassment to yourself.
April 26, 2011 at 7:35 pm
SerJew
“Bizarre and nonsensical.” church lady
Deep and edifying. <—that´s irony, in case you didn´t get it.
April 26, 2011 at 7:49 pm
pretzelberg
SerJew
You display the prototypical leftist commissar mentality,
More hilarity! Keep it going if only for entertainment’s sake!
And “Church-lady”?? What church would that be, Mr. Bigot?
April 26, 2011 at 7:54 pm
pretzelberg
SerJew 7:35 pm
Deep and edifying. <—that´s irony, in case you didn´t get it.
In English the term is “sarcasm” not “irony”.
Either way: humour’s not your strong point. Move on.
April 26, 2011 at 8:01 pm
SerJew
“And “Church-lady”?? What church would that be, Mr. Bigot” commissar pretlize
Oh, don´t tell me you don´t know!? It´s the Church of Self-Appointed Paragons of Immaculate Global Humanitarian Harmony and Social Perfection.
You are part of that cult of purificationists, which is what was left of the Left after 1989. And you inherited the same self-defeating traits of the previous Left, the same hubris, self-righteouness and potential for disaster.
April 26, 2011 at 8:05 pm
SerJew
“In English the term is “sarcasm” not “irony”.
Either way: humour’s not your strong point. Move on.” pretlize
Really? You don´t even seem to know the meaning of humour. Which partly
explains why you can´t “move on”. You are stuck. But that´s your problem. Deal with it yourself instead of dumping it on other people.
April 26, 2011 at 8:40 pm
Hoi Polloi
“And I see Hoi Polloi is likewise bringing down the standard of debate to something below juvenile.”
The View from the Gutter
Starring
Linda Grant
Gary Younge
Mark Thomas
Guest Appearance
Samir Kuntar
Gaffer
pretzelberg
Director
Alan Rusbridger
An Anti-Zionist Production for the Islamic Resistance Movement
——————-
“Reminds me of those sad posters on Cif who clearly have no friends in real life.”
This from an individual who was raised at 4 Battersea Park Road.
April 27, 2011 at 12:33 am
pretzelberg
SerJew
Really? You don´t even seem to know the meaning of humour.
I certainly do. While you preach hate.
April 27, 2011 at 3:47 am
Abban Aziz
Back on topic – forget the words. Just look at the pictures. Study Israel’s demographic. There is nothing “white” about Israel. The Palestinians are many times more homogeneous than the Israelis. There is very little diversity in Palestinian society, mostly because minorities are choked into shoddy towns or driven out all together.
Slavery was once practiced by the Arabs in Palestine until the Ottoman’s later eradicated it. Wonder if Young knows this?
April 27, 2011 at 4:17 am
Andy Gill
All Jews look alike to Gary Younge.
April 27, 2011 at 4:56 am
JerusalemMite
Abban Aziz
Just look at the pictures. Study Israel’s demographic. There is nothing “white” about Israel.
Surely you are not expecting the ‘hate Israel’ CiFallists to be swayed by pictures or other ‘difficult’ facts?
April 27, 2011 at 8:52 am
Hoi Polloi
“All Jews look alike to Gary Younge.”
All Israel-haters look alike to me:
http://tinyurl.com/5v4txqb
http://tinyurl.com/4xkz3qr
April 27, 2011 at 10:15 am
profil97
Ziontruth
“But Progressives like Younge don’t accept that”
He isn’t a quote-unquote progressive in my book. Gary Younge is a third world-oriented ideologue, who sees things in black-n-white divides, literally.
Again, many thanks for your comment.
April 27, 2011 at 10:20 am
profil97
“Why the reference to Jamaica? Cause you assume he comes from there?
Dodgy racist crap. Shut the f— up”
Not sure who you’ve managed to infer all that. Needless to say it isn’t so.
As for your closing remark, Go wash your mouth with soap, idiot!!!
April 27, 2011 at 10:33 am
profil97
Adam Levick
“Please note: Garry Younge’s physical characteristics are completely irrelevant, and represent an ad hominem attack. Any references made, explicitly or implicitly, to such traits will be deleted”
All is fair in love and war.
Gary Younge sides with the Arabs for one reason only. On average, they have a darker skin tone than Israeli Jews.
Nothing carries more weight [ no pun intended ] in his color-coded Weltanschauung than being of darker complexion.
April 27, 2011 at 11:34 am
ziontruth
profil97,
Those are not mutually exclusive categories in our day and age. “Progressive” has nothing to do with actual progress, just as “liberal,” at least in the American political arena, has nothing to do with classical liberal values.
As proof, consider race-baiters Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton, who are the photographic negatives of David Duke and other KKK’ers in their hatred of white people, yet consider themselves “Progressives.” Haters of whites, Jews and Christians have found the modern “Progressive” Left a welcoming home.