This is a cross post by Benjamin Weinthal from an article that appeared in the Jewish Press
As an Israeli psychoanalyst once noted with bitter irony, the Germans will never forgive the Jews for Auschwitz. The corollary to this observation is that Europeans will never forgive the Israelis and the Jews for Auschwitz.
How can one explain the latest outbreak of European loathing for the Jewish state after it intercepted a flotilla heading for Gaza in open violation of a naval blockade? The widespread condemnation Europeans have expressed toward Israel after its commandos boarded the so-called peace flotilla on May 31 – and used force only when threatened with death – signals a desire to turn every Israeli action of self-defense into absolution for the crimes of the Holocaust.
While the European Union and the UN Human Rights Council somehow manage to contain their displeasure over brutal human rights violations in Libya, Iran, Turkey, China and Russia, both organizations reacted in their standard Pavlovian way to Israel’s justified measures of self-defense aboard the Turkish ship Mavi Marmara.
The UN Human Rights Council – chaired by none other than Colonel Khaddafi’s government – issued a resolution condemning Israel. Meanwhile, France, Germany, Italy, Spain and the United Kingdom blasted Israel’s “disproportionate” response, and their handmaidens in the European media turned Israel into a punching bag.
The Europeans’ vicious attacks on Israel are animated less by the Jewish state’s foreign policy than by Europe’s ongoing fixation on the Holocaust. What else could explain the presence of posters equating Israel with Nazi Germany at pro-Hamas demonstrations in Vienna? According to one recent German university study, 45.7 percent of the European respondents supported the contention that “Israel is conducting a war of extermination against the Palestinians.”
In their eyes, apparently, maintaining a naval blockade against a government sworn to destroy you – while providing the unfortunate people living under that government with tens of thousands of tons of supplies and humanitarian aid – now equates to looting and butchering six million people.
Wolfgang Benz, the controversial director of the Berlin Center for the study of anti-Semitism, neatly summed up this incongruity on German television when he insisted that “anti-Semitism is different from anti-Zionism.”
Benz embodies the European wish to alleviate guilt by denying the weight of the Holocaust. (As the head of a center for the study of anti-Semitism, he’s a particularly strange case; the German political scientist Dr. Clemens Heni discovered that Benz’s beloved academic mentor was the now-deceased Karl Bosl, an outspoken Nazi who contributed enormously to spreading Hitler’s ideology.)
Of course, nothing Israel has ever done can even begin to compare to the crimes of the Shoah. But to help alleviate their feelings of guilt, Europeans delegitimize Israel, ignore modern anti-Semitism, and portray Muslims – who number over one billion and whom no one seeks to eradicate from the earth – as the new persecuted Jews of Europe.
Israel’s measures against the phony peace flotilla also provided Europeans an opportunity to demonstrate their hypocrisy when it comes to Jews flexing some muscle. Many of these same Europeans, after all, have attempted to shift at least some blame to the Jewish victims of the Holocaust for their own suffering, arguing that the Jews allowed themselves to be carted off to extermination camps without resistance.
That helps explain the crude theory of Ekkehart Krippendorff, a Berlin Free University professor in the 1990s, who wrote in the left-liberal Tagesszeitung, “Imagine if no German Jews had followed orders to assemble at the designated collection points for group transports – a few dozen, a few hundred, maybe a few thousand, the Germans could have dragged individually from their homes and loaded on trucks; but hundreds of thousands? Or imagine that the colonies of hundreds and thousands on the way to the train stations had simply sat down, we call them ‘sit-down’ strikes today .”
Europe is infatuated with passive Jews and memorial events for dead ones. When Jews actually strike back, Europeans cry that they have reacted disproportionately and failed to engage in diplomacy with the terrorist entities that seek their demise.
Europeans also vent pathological guilt about the Shoah by elevating Jewish conduct to a higher standard because of it. The standard European posture toward Israel is to present Auschwitz as a cynical form of cognitive and behavioral therapy. This particular European view has caught on with Turkey’s Foreign Minister, Ahmet Davutoglu, who recently told The New York Times that the Israelis are uniquely positioned to be reminded about the “the dangers and inhumanity of ghettoes [such] as the one we currently witness in occupied Gaza.”
The equation of Gaza with the Warsaw ghetto is perhaps the most prevalent analogy used by Europeans in their attempts to shake off guilt about the Holocaust. Consider the German Catholic bishops Gregor Maria Hanke and Walter Mixa, who, while visiting Israel in March 2007, equated it with Nazi Germany.
“This morning we saw pictures of the Warsaw Ghetto at Yad Vashem and this evening we are going to the Ramallah ghetto,” Hanke said. To Mixa, Ramallah was “ghetto-like” and “almost racism.” While Pope Benedict XVI sacked his Bavarian friend Mixa in April on the basis of financial and sexual improprieties, that view enjoys many proponents across Europe.
The shoddy one-sided accounts of the flotilla raid with which Europeans have comforted themselves, and the continual denial of any Jewish right to self-defense, reveal exactly what the psychoanalyst observed: a Europe that will never forgive the Jews for Auschwitz.
Benjamin Weinthal is a fellow at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies (www.defenddemocracy.org).





16 comments
Comments feed for this article
July 2, 2010 at 2:21 am
Gerald Kreeve
Europe idolizes dead Shoah victims, disparages live Israelis.
July 2, 2010 at 3:32 am
Millfield
Are we to infer from this article, that with the plethora of Holocaust museums springing up all over Europe, that the Europeans are infact raising monuments to the celebration of the Shoah rather than its commemeration?
In Los Angeles the Holocaust Museum is named the Museum of Tolearance. Would The Museum of Intolerance be a more truthful representation?
One thing is for sure that if G-forbid Israel was subject to an attack with WMD the United Nations would never admit to its guilt in failing to prevent (if not actually encouraging) the means for the manufacture and use of such WMD by Israel’s enemies.
On the contrary the UN and the European press would vigorously assert that Israel had it coming and had only itself to blame. Their phony sympathy would only be for any Palestinians caught by friendly fire, whilst the Islamic world would visualise such Palestinian casualities as noble martyrs for the cause.
Thus it has been so for 2000 years
July 2, 2010 at 3:40 am
benorr
When Israeli’s go to war ,they are in there to fight for their lives,and hopefully to come out alive,this is not a smiling contest,and definitely not a Hollywood photo shoot.
It’s kill or get killed,this must be made very clear to our enemies.Because they still haven’t got used to the idea,that there is a new breed of Jew that has learned to fight back,and fight back good.They are stunned that a Jew would actually hit them back.They are just not used to this new Jewish behaior.
For the Turks this was a very traumatic experience,they thought that they were dealing with the usual unarmed Kurds that they kick around.
We should shed our thin skins,and stop being so touchy to every idiot who writes bad things about us,Ben White is a nothing,just a sniveling little coward who is trying to take on the appearance of a Nazi.The haircut,the smirk,the beady little blue eyes.And the mind set of a Nazi.
I’m sure that if he were ever to be confronted in person he would soil and wet his pants.
July 2, 2010 at 6:02 am
HairShirt
Millfield, well I can’t help but wonder whether many of them wish it had succeeded totally, regardless of what they may say about the horror of it.
I also agree with you that the UN would not act if Israel were attacked by WMD. If the events leading up to Cast Lead, with the exchanges of letters between the Israeli prime minister and the Security Council are anything to go by – when Israel’s plea for UN intervention to prevent increasing shelling of civilians in southern Israel went unanswered and unheeded – then, to paraphrase a Jewish joke I once heard, “On them we shouldn’t rely.”
@Benjamin – “…Europe is infatuated with passive Jews and memorial events for dead ones. When Jews actually strike back, Europeans cry that they have reacted disproportionately and failed to engage in diplomacy with the terrorist entities that seek their demise…”
Right on the button.
Benorr I agree that Israel/Jewish people are too thin skinned. Once we accept that whatever we do and however we do it, there’ll always be hatred from the barely functional of Jews for being Jews, which is in turn manipulated and made use of by the likes of al Groan and Islamist factions and their mindless supporters in the west, then there can be a curious sort of freedom which comes from being able to take the gloves off and wade into them and pay back in kind, and tenfold.
In the UK we can begin, Jews and others, by making a huge fuss about the recent verdict of not guilty on the five who broke into an armaments factory in the UK in January 2009 and caused substantial damage. Their case was built around the fact that they did it “for the greater good” and to prevent Israeli war crimes in Gaza(!)
The judge was wheeled out of retirement to hear the case and it transpired that he had been born in Palestine to British parents. He shamefully led the jury to acquit, which of course sets a disastrous legal precedent and means that it can in theory (although I devoutly hope not) be open season on mosques and madrassas who teach Jew-hatred and hatred and violence towards kufar to prevent their attacking Jews and others, also acting “for the greater good.” As I said, I hope that would never happen, and for that reason, I believe that the verdict will be overturned on appeal.
The Groan reported it at
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/jun/30/activists-arms-factory-acquitted
And for another, much more detailed account of what actually took place in the court:
http://atlasshrugs2000.typepad.com/atlas_shrugs/2010/07/brit-jury-acquits-criminals-who-destroyed-arms-factory-because-their-motive-was-jew-hatred-.html
July 2, 2010 at 6:10 am
Derek Pasquill
I wonder if the British historian, Arnold Toynbee, was the first, in the mid-fifties, to suggest that Israel’s fall from Grace into Original Sin (expelling the Palestinians) was of a higher order of magnitude than Nazi Germany’s crime of extermination, because as prior victims the Israelis should have had the moral strength to resist this sort of morally-debased behaviour.
According to Toynbee. Who is extraordinarily difficult to read as one struggles with his peculiar, religion-inflected mania. I wonder if large swathes of progressive liberal opinion suffer a similar mania albeit of secular hue.
July 2, 2010 at 6:49 am
HairShirt
Derek Pasquill, I am glad that you refer to Toynbee’s religiosity as a mania.
I almost fell out with a good friend of longstanding who made a similar point to Toynbee’s along the lines that “the Jews should know better… we expect much more of them..” etc, etc, after the Lebanese war. Interestingly this bloke is a devout Christian although not a bible basher and he got a nest of termites, rather than a flea, in his ear.
There seems not only to be religious and secular mania about what Israel does, but a peculiar sort of blindness too.
July 2, 2010 at 6:58 am
pretzelberg
As an Israeli psychoanalyst once noted with bitter irony, the Germans will never forgive the Jews for Auschwitz.
Ze germans? All 80 million of them? Including my missus??
What a load of bullshit.
July 2, 2010 at 7:00 am
pretzelberg
Millfield
One thing is for sure that if G-forbid Israel was subject to an attack with WMD … the UN and the European press would vigorously assert that Israel had it coming and had only itself to blame.
For G*d’s sake see a doctor, man.
July 2, 2010 at 7:07 am
AKUS
Derek Pasquill –
“because as prior victims the Israelis should have had the moral strength to resist this sort of morally-debased behaviour.”
there is definitely an element of what you say in the assertions that its right to condemn Israel and ignore, say, China’s record because Israel is a Western country and should be judged by Western standards (even though they are not applied to Western countries).
There is also the endless repetition of “have they learned nothing from their treatment in the Holocaust” (even though, of course, very few of us were “treated” in the Holocaust) as excuses for the rabid anti-semitism we see in media such as the Guardian and Huffington Post.
July 2, 2010 at 8:05 am
Millfield
Pretzelburg
No doubt you would have said the same in the 1930′s.
Which doctor should we see then?
Herr Doctor Eichman, Doctor Mengele etc
Of the 14 senior Nazi officials attending the Wannsee Conference in 1942 for the Final Solution 8 of them had doctorates
Seriously – The statement maybe a bit OTT but I doubt many left liberals on CIF would loose any sleep if Israel was destroyed nor would the 55 Islamic nations in the UN nor the dozens of other dictatorships
July 2, 2010 at 8:14 am
Yohoho
Millfield, left liberals would lose sleep big time (or sleep forever to use a euphemism) if Israel were destroyed. This would open the door for Islamist brutality in the west, which is sleep-walking slowily towards widespread complicit support for, if not countenancing Islamist excesses already.
July 2, 2010 at 9:34 am
benorr
There are thousands of ways to pay back these people in kind,use their own tactics,and more, not all of these tactics can be printed here.
These idiots do whatever they like and get away with it,no one even bothers to stop them.Complaining does nothing.Let them do the complaining for a change.
If we can defend ourselves very so well in Israel,why are we so bad at it overseas.
I learned very early in life that bullies fold when confronted,of course you need a bit of muscle to back yourself up.
July 3, 2010 at 12:05 am
Berchmans
Yohoho
“Millfield, left liberals would lose sleep big time (or sleep forever to use a euphemism) if Israel were destroyed. ”
I like to check in every now and again to see if there is any change…any news ideas. I guess I can relax!
Peace to all
July 4, 2010 at 2:53 pm
Millfield
Prezelburg
You recall that in your now removed comment you advised that in profaning His name I should see a doctor.
Well my retort of July 2nd 8.05 refers.
If you make such offensive comments I will bite back and bite hard
Berchmans will testify to that. At the moment I have a truce with him although I note his comment of 12.05. Naughty, naughty Berchmans !
July 4, 2010 at 4:58 pm
pretzelberg
Millfield
If you make such offensive comments I will bite back and bite hard
To imply that I’m some kind of Nazi apologist makes you a laughing stock.
July 4, 2010 at 6:22 pm
Millfield
Prezelburg
I do not in any way imply or believe that you are a Nazi. I was being subtlely humourous, maybe a little bit sarcastic to highlight your offensive remark that I should see a doctor.
I now understand why other have referred to your thinking processes as one that takes everything literally