The distressing news that Israel’s Deputy Ambassador to the UK had been attacked by violent ‘pro-Palestinian’ protestors on April 28th at the University of Manchester came as no surprise to me: it is an event which has been in the making for a long time, the build-up to which I watched unfold with my own eyes during the time I worked on that campus.
Throughout Operation Cast Lead and for several weeks following it, the atmosphere on campus was one of aggression and menace as students staged demonstrations and occupied part of the university. Working in a building close to the Students Union, I found myself having to listen to hours of hostile chants through a megaphone and obliged to negotiate anti-Israeli posters, placards and demonstrations just to get out of the building and to the bus stop. On several occasions I was accosted by activists handing out of leaflets or soliciting donations. When I declined to contribute, a torrent of verbal abuse followed which became even uglier when the Star of David I wear was spotted. In February 2009 the Student Union newspaper reported that a Jewish SU leader had threatening graffiti scrawled on his door. Make no mistake; these protests were anti-Israeli, not pro-Palestinian.
Much of the activism at Manchester and other British universities is organised by a group called ‘Action Palestine’ which works together with organisations which will be familiar to many readers such as Jews for Justice for Palestinians, ICAHD UK, Friends of Al Aqsa, Machsom Watch, The Palestine Solidarity Campaign, BRICUP and the Stop the War Coalition. Among these organisations, Machsom Watch and ICAHD at least have received EU funding which they use to promote the delegitimisation of Israel. ICAHD UK advocates a boycott of Israeli goods based upon what it calls ‘the Manchester model’. In other words, the harassment of Israeli and Jewish students and staff at British universities is being aided by organizations receiving funding from British tax payers via the EU.
In December 2009, BRICUP organised a tour of several British universities including Manchester by the notorious South African trade union leader Bongani Masuku, together with Ronnie Kasrils and Omar Barghouti. At the time, my objections to the university hosting such promoters of hatred were dismissed on the basis of ‘academic freedom of expression’. In February 2010 an exhibition of Israeli science and technology at the Manchester Museum of Science and Industry was the target of a campaign by assorted pro-Palestinian groups whose letter of objection to the exhibition was published in the then Guardian Media Group owned Manchester Evening News as well as in the Guardian itself. Also in February, Ms. Lador–Fresher was forced to cancel her planned talk at the University of Manchester due to a campaign by Action Palestine which included demonstrations and the statement that “we are calling a Protest against Israeli War Crimes in Palestine at 2 pm outside the Students Union steps before the Pol Soc meeting on the 18th to show Mrs Talya Lador-Fresher that neither she or the state she represents are welcome on the premises of our democratically run Union that prides itself on being a student-run establishment which does not endorse nor fund apartheid regimes responsible for the deaths of thousands of innocent civilians. “
Despite this, Ms Lador-Fresher bravely tried once more to exercise her right to speak at the university’s Political Society this week. The intimidation she suffered as a result gives out a very clear message: the basic rights of Israelis to free speech and personal safety are being deliberately suppressed by these activists. There is to be no opportunity for debate, no exchange of ideas and no respect for differing points of view. This is a generation of students which is not only being raised to believe that Israel is an illegitimate, apartheid state, but which is being denied the opportunity to discover any differing point of view on the subject. This is also a generation which is being raised with warped ideas of democracy in which the rule of intimidation and menace prevents the expression of ideas and beliefs deemed unacceptable to those who promote their political agenda by shouting down others. It is a generation for whom the concept of the human rights of one minority group- Jews- to freedom of expression and self determination are already foreign, and it would be a mistake to believe that such disregard will begin and end with Jews. Worryingly, it is also the generation from which Britain’s future leaders will spring, and that should be cause for concern to every right-thinking person in British society today.






60 comments
Comments feed for this article
April 30, 2010 at 8:45 am
Zionist Federation Press Notice
The Zionist Federation unreservedly condemns the attack on the Deputy Ambassador of the State of Israel last night. It calls on the police and the University to take the strictest possible action against these would-be deniers of free speech. Those reponsible must be sent down from the unversity and prosecuted if responsible for criminal damage.
It is the abject failure of university Vice Chancellors to deal with extremism which fuels this kind of hateful action. Do we have to have serious injury or a death before Vice Chancellors see that the right to protest does not include the right to endanger life and limb?
The ZF again calls on Universities UK to stop extremist action at Universities; if it cannot, the next government has to step in quickly. The Universities were asked to act in 2006, in the Report of the All Party Committee on Antisemitism. But – as was shown last night and as is shown by the numbers of former Islamic Society activists who have been arrested and/or charged for terrorist offences – inaction opens the door to campus extremism.
April 30, 2010 at 8:53 am
Annekl
What I find almost as disgraceful is the fact that as far as I know, not one British newspaper or website has reported on this disgusting event, besides the Jewish media. You can be sure that if it were Jewish students merely heckling a Palestinian-supporter it would have been splashed all over the British media as “Jewish anti-democratic actions”.
Democracy for me but not for thee it would seem in today’s Britain.
April 30, 2010 at 8:59 am
FoolMeOnce
“So Shall You Reap”
This might just happen on a national level for Britain if the Lib-Dems led by Nick Clegg edge over the Tories in the upcoming election. Polls suggest it’s a close call.
I’m writing this because this Nick Clegg is the very epitome of the kind of rabid mutation of the Liberal left you write about. It’s no longer criticism of Israel, its criticism of its existence:
Nick Clegg: ‘Israel Jewish?’
http://www.thejc.com/news/world-news/nick-clegg-israel-jewish%E2%80%99
It’s no longer recognition of the injustices of the past and present, made by Britain as all countries do occasionally, it’s twisting that too, beyond the realm of reason:
Nick Clegg: Britain bears cross ‘bigger than Germany’s Nazi past’
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/election-2010/7616685/Nick-Clegg-Britain-bears-cross-bigger-than-Germanys-Nazi-past.html
This is what Britain might be putting in office very soon. “So Shall You Reap” indeed.
April 30, 2010 at 9:04 am
Gerald Kreeve
Fair play and good judgement don’t seem to rule at UK universities any more. What has happened to people like CP Scott, the founder of the Manchester Guardian? What has happened to people like Winston Churchill? Have their voices been silenced by the forces of the new UK?
April 30, 2010 at 9:18 am
THH
You can’t blame those students , they are so enraged by the brutal and oppressive Zionist Occupation that they just can’t hold themselves from violent acts , just like Palestinians , they are so poor and miserable that you can’t blame them for not using common sense , not using their heads , using violence to solve any conflict etc ….
April 30, 2010 at 9:37 am
JonathanH
@Annekl
Both the BBC and Associated Press have been given the story.
If the BBC and other MSM choose not to run it, draw your own conclusion.
April 30, 2010 at 9:54 am
JerusalemMite
In February 2010 an exhibition of Israeli science and technology at the Manchester Museum of Science and Industry was the target of a campaign by assorted pro-Palestinian groups whose letter of objection to the exhibition was published in the then Guardian Media Group owned Manchester Evening News as well as in the Guardian itself.
That caught my eye.
Surely you are not suggesting that The Guardian is ‘pro Palestinian’? Heavens. That would mean that Porgina’s letter to the Jewish Chronicle informing them that the Guardian/CiF was ‘fair and balanced’ was a lie.
(Gasp)
April 30, 2010 at 10:15 am
Annekl
JonathanH, I was working on the assumption that they know of the story, and yes, I have indeed drawn my own sad conclusions. Perhaps they’ll be a bit embarrassed now that the story is out in the JC, which is as near to mainstream as a Jewish paper can get, and publish the story. Or perhaps not; we’ll see.
April 30, 2010 at 10:20 am
smtx01
last year a group of Young Israeli’s selling dead sea salts in a Belfast shopping centre were attacked, i dont recall much on the news then either
April 30, 2010 at 10:21 am
smtx01
perhaps a few Israeli spokesman could get a voice and start outlining stuff!
April 30, 2010 at 10:27 am
smtx01
so shall you reap so shall you sow. As long as Israel continues to remain silent and impotent on the attacks on Jews in the diaspora and visiting israeli diplomats being attacked, or having arrest warrants issued, im sure it will continue, employ a frigen PR officer for goodness sake, seek a wider audiance than, here. where we all already know the score
April 30, 2010 at 10:31 am
smtx01
How to fight deligitimization? GET A VOICE!! it is not just up to diaspora Jews to state Israels case and to challenge the boycotters. Israel needs to step up its game
April 30, 2010 at 11:18 am
pretzelberg
“Make no mistake; these protests were anti-Israeli, not pro-Palestinian.”
Indeed – and that’s also the impression I get re. certain CiF posters.
April 30, 2010 at 11:18 am
Questor
Professor Malcolm Grant is heading the post-underpants bomber enquiry into Extremism in UK Universities.
http://www.universitiesuk.ac.uk/Newsroom/Media-Releases/Pages/Update1workinggroup.aspx
Tell him what you think about the attack on Israel’s Deputy Ambassador in Manchester on 29 April, and about Islamist and hard left student delegitimisation of Israel and propagation of antisemitism at British universities.
provost@ucl.ac.uk
tel: +44 (0)20 7679 7234
fax: +44 (0)20 7388 5412
email: provost@ucl.ac.uk
April 30, 2010 at 11:19 am
smtx01
Anyway, enough for today, lets all have a good weekend, appreciate our days and our time. dont let the haters get to you. Shabat Shalom to everyone
shalom and have a lovely evening to everyone
@Pretzel 4th spot still looking good to me
April 30, 2010 at 11:37 am
JerusalemMite
Questor
Tell him what you think about the attack on Israel’s Deputy Ambassador in Manchester on 29 April, and about Islamist and hard left student delegitimisation of Israel and propagation of antisemitism at British universities.
Thanks.
I will.
April 30, 2010 at 11:44 am
Andy Gill
There is a simple solution. Universities which tolerate extremism and anti-semitism should have their funding cut. In a period of public funding cuts, this would be a good way to save money.
April 30, 2010 at 11:49 am
Andy Gill
To express your disgust, write to the President and Vice-Chancellor, Professor Alan Gilbert at
president@manchester.ac.uk
April 30, 2010 at 12:02 pm
Heres to Davy.
” the basic rights of Israelis to free speech and personal safety are being deliberately suppressed by these activists. ”
This is another careful and sensitive article . Whilst I would not die to allow a representative of Israeli to speak..given the horror that the country has been involved in recently ..I deplore any such cowardly and counterproductive violence.
It seems sexist to say that violence against a women is worse but there you go.
April 30, 2010 at 12:26 pm
Serendipity
Andy Gill, I agree with you, but that won’t cover the universities funded by Saudi and other Islamist countries.
Questor, this is what I have written to Prof Grant:
“I am appalled and disgusted at the attack on Israel’s Deputy Ambassador in Manchester on 29 April.
“I share others’ concern about Islamist and hard left student delegitimisation of Israel and propagation of antisemitism at British universities generally, including at my own university ********
“The United Kingdom has a hard-won tradition of allowing the right of free expression to anyone who uses it within the law. I would never seek to change this, but the thugs who perpetrated this outrage and perverted this right to serve their own ignominious ends deserve to be punished by the full weight of the law and any who are members of Manchester University should be expelled forthwith.
“Yours sincerely….”
April 30, 2010 at 12:28 pm
Yohoho
Berchmans, would you die to allow a representative of Hamas or Hezbollah to speak? If so, why, given the horrors both have perpetrated against their own people and against Israel?
April 30, 2010 at 1:02 pm
peterthehungarian
I understand the silence of the mainstream British media, leftist intellectuals and politicians. This attack and the lack of police/law enforcement reaction is the direct consequence of their incessant incitement against Israel, they are responsible too for this disgrace, especially the so called left wing organs like the Guardian, BBC etc.
The reaction of the University’s spokesperson: “The University is fundamentally committed to freedom of speech, exercised within the law. It follows that it should also allow peaceful and lawful protest to take place on its campus.” speaks for itself.
These are the standards of a British university regarding “peace” and law” in the XXI. century? It seems to me the answer is a big yes – naturally if this lawful and peaceful pogrom attempt is directed against an Israeli Jew.
April 30, 2010 at 1:21 pm
Israelinurse
Some of today’s University lecturers appear to find current student activities romantically reminiscent of their own student days –
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/education/education-news/students-are-revolting-the-spirit-of-68-is-reawakening-1604043.html
April 30, 2010 at 1:54 pm
Heres to Davy.
Yohoho
” Berchmans, would you die to allow a representative of Hamas or Hezbollah to speak? ”
They’re both pretty controversial. They have caused the deaths of about a dozen Israelis ( in the case of the former) in the past year or so and even tho this is nothing compared to the deaths caused by Israel this is still ghastly.
April 30, 2010 at 2:38 pm
Yvetta Bagel
Sadly, I’m shocked yet not totally surprised by the lack of coverage by the BBC of this nauseating incident by the bovver boys and girls of the totaliarian left.
After all, Al Beeb rarely reports violence against Jews in France and Belgium (and not by Le Pen’s mob, if you get my drift!); I learn of such violence (more often than not) from, of all places, my airmail copy of “The Australian Jewish News”!
If the violence had come from rightwing sources, however …
The silence of my paper of choice, the “Daily Telegraph”, is, however, rather amazing.
April 30, 2010 at 5:19 pm
PeterParker
pretzelberg:
Indeed – and that’s also the impression I get re. certain CiF posters.
Whoever could you be refering to?
Live long and prosper.
April 30, 2010 at 5:31 pm
TomWonacott
Israelinurse
“…….Make no mistake; these protests were anti-Israeli, not pro Palestinian…..”
That, of course, defines the far left. They oppose Israel (and America) above all else. For example, this post by Berchmans (from above).
“……..They’re both [Hamas and Hezbollah] pretty controversial. They have caused the deaths of about a dozen Israelis ( in the case of the former) in the past year or so and even tho this is nothing compared to the deaths caused by Israel this is still ghastly……” my brackets
Instead of being brutal human rights abusers in their own right and terrorist that target civilians, they are just “controversial”. Most important in his statement, however, is that Israel is far worse.
The whole idea behind the left’s war on Israel is that to justify support for terrorist like Hamas including their brutal treatment of women and children, Israel must be made to appear far worse, thus the comparisons to apartheid South Africa and Nazi Germany – and the “massacre” in Gaza.
From today’s thread, Orwellwasright:
“……It is in large part this simplistic and distorted view of Hamas….”
The wacko left even defends Hamas. Definitely anti Israel, not pro Palestinian. How could you be pro Palestinian knowing that Hamas operates contrary to the interests of Palestinians – like making the decision to go to war with Israel knowing that thousands of Palestinians could be killed?
April 30, 2010 at 5:58 pm
AKUS
The Guardian has seen fit to publish a long article on Goldstone’s “banning” from his grandson’s bar-mitzvah:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/apr/30/richard-goldstone-south-africa-jews
but managed to completely ignore this horrifying event in Manchester (of course, its no longer the “Manchester Guardian”).
Truly, as the title of this article reads, Goldstone is learning “as you sow, so shall you reap”.
The lesson the students involved, the Guardian, and, belatedly, Goldstone, need to take to heart, that these attacks on Israel and Jews are not a one way street, and will eventually turn on those who started them.
As for the Guardian’s reference to South African judge Albie Sachs suporting Goldstone, they, of course omitted the counter article by Maurice Ostroff:
http://www.2nd-thoughts.org/id273.html
April 30, 2010 at 6:03 pm
michael reik
The effect of the anti Israel attacks this week in Manchester is a continuing build up after the problems at UC in London and at Soas in London following the Labour Government taking away any control over the University Chancellors, under the banner of Free Speech. It seems Free Speech means with this Government as long as we do not lose votes we will allow attacks to take place. Hopefully they( believe) will only be of a verbal nature. The situation this week in Manchester may change this but I believe it may only be sorted if a Conservative Government comes into office as they are committed to taking back control of the Universty Chancellors.
MKR
April 30, 2010 at 9:57 pm
Toko LeMoko
Israelinurse – Strangely enough, I have to agree with the Telegrap when it states that “[Radical-left, "activist"] Students are revolting.”
;-}
May 1, 2010 at 12:10 am
Heres to Davy.
TomWonacott
” in his statement, however, is that Israel is far worse. ”
Hamas for example has had people killed…they have done this presumably making the decisions in basements scurrying from the IDF with no oversight or democratic restraint.
When Israel kills people it does it following open cabinet discussion with time to reflect ..with the checks and balances of a pluralistic democracy operating. Qne is gangsters running about in debris ..the other is apparently responsible citizens causing thousands of deaths of poor people.
“She asked to get battered your honour. “
May 1, 2010 at 12:43 am
spoton
These palestinians bring their shit with them where ever they go.It’s no wonder that they got thrown out of,Jordan,Iraq,Kuwait,and a few other places.
They haven’t heard of the saying,you don’t shit into the plate that you eat from.
Not nice people.
May 1, 2010 at 12:54 am
peterthehungarian
Berchmans
Summing up your opinion:
Hamas murdering their own = poor understandable sinners
Israel protecting itself from rockets = baby killers
This is something like this:
Iran on UN women’s rights c’tee
May 1, 2010 at 1:00 am
spoton
The Israeli Embassy should have provided security for the Israeli Deputy Ambassador,instead of leaving her to the mercy of these palestinian ferals.
As to these British cops,they are effing useless,as useful as feathers on a frog.
Where were these British Jews that should have been there to counter these regular riots.
Too busy writing for the Guardian.
May 1, 2010 at 1:09 am
spoton
The only reason the palestinians exist is for the grace of Israel.
If Israel did not exist, there would be no palestine or palestinians.No Jordan,no Lebanon.
The Arab states would be at each others throats,carving up these states.
May 1, 2010 at 2:16 am
Greensleeves
Hamas for example has had people killed…they have done this presumably making the decisions in basements scurrying from the IDF with no oversight or democratic restraint.
Rats, in short?
No, you’re thinking of Nasrullah here.
Hamas make decisions in rooms lit with candles, with the curtains drawn tightly to keep out the sun that keeps obstinately peeping in.
May 1, 2010 at 5:11 am
FoolMeOnce
Yesterday morning: “Jew attacked with knife, iron rod in France”
http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3883121,00.html
May 1, 2010 at 5:53 am
THH
@FoolMeOnce
The French authorities say that it wasn’t antisemitism , it was 2 Mentally ill with galabias over their head .
May 1, 2010 at 6:18 am
MindTheCrap
Was this Manchester story covered by the Guardian? I did a quick search but couldn’t find it. Please post the link if the story does exist. Thanks.
May 1, 2010 at 10:09 am
Heres to Davy.
Greensleeves
Rats, in short?
The poster Rapunzel who posts here as Punzie once gubbed me a good one for associating people with rats. She reminded me of the Nazi films .I havent dared repeat such a thoughtless comparison.
May 1, 2010 at 10:15 am
THH
@Heres to Davy.
This is what he meant , not rats , just liers .
May 1, 2010 at 10:16 am
THH
so no picture embedding?
http://www.reformislam.org/images/HamasCandelight.jpg
this is the link .
They act as they don’t have electricity so they put on a show by closing the drapes ( you can see its day outside ) and lighting candles .
May 1, 2010 at 10:19 am
Yohoho
Berchmans you side-step the question as I thought you might and you look the absolute weasel that you are.
For anyone who wants it, the address of Prof Gilbert at Manchester University Write and ask him what he’s going to do to protect the rights of free speech for everyone at Manchester, not only the Islamists who terrify the university authorities, and whether he’s going to expel those Manchester University students (and sack any staff) who participated in this:
president@manchester.ac.uk
May 1, 2010 at 10:26 am
Yohoho
Berchmans: “…“She asked to get battered your honour. “,
You are in effect saying the same thing and excusing the batterers whenever you bleat that the Palestinians can’t help themselves or stop Hamas from encouraging their children or women to explode among or otherwise kill Israeli Jews, and you are minimising the Jew-hatred they spew out.
You’ve also said in the past here that you have been driven to make antisemitic remarks because of the way in which your drivel has come under attack by more intelligent posters.
None of this will wash. You should have taken responsibility for your own actions in all these cases, just as you should be encouraging the Palestinians to take responsibility for their own futures and opt for peace, rather than perpetuating their “poor us” codependency like other loony left idiots.
May 1, 2010 at 10:30 am
Serendipity
See Mira Vogel’s article at
http://engageonline.wordpress.com/2010/04/30/violence-against-israeli-speaker-is-not-an-isolated-incident/
And particularly the two replies from Adam, who seems as if he would feel more at home among Berchmans’ friends at the other place.
(Berchmans, are you “Adam” by any chance?)
May 1, 2010 at 10:41 am
HairShirt
MichaelReik, I doubt that the next government, of whatever political stripe will effect any change. In my area I am sickened by the extent to which the three major ones go to whore themselves for the Muslim vote.
My town is a model of peaceful coexistence between all races, creeds and cultures, but given the lack of spine of peaceful and peaceable Muslims I doubt that they could fend off attempts to overrun them by Islamists. I believe that it’s only a matter of time.
And Islamism in Britain has been the elephant in the room in all the inter party public debates. All are terrified of addressing our concerns, much less telling us what they intend to do about them.
And I have seen and heard nothing to encourage me to believe that the Conservatives would be different if they got elected.
May 1, 2010 at 10:54 am
Heres to Davy.
Yohoho
” you look the absolute weasel that you are. ”
This is better than “rat” …as there have been no films made to dehumanise people by depicting them as weasels. Unless you know of any and you are being autre and clever…ridiculous tho such a concept is:)
.
“You’ve also said in the past here that you have been driven to make antisemitic remarks because of the way in which your drivel has come under attack by more intelligent posters.”
.
Doesnt sound like something I would say. Firstly I would not make an antisemitic remark …but also I have still to encounter these posters you mention!
Serendipity
” are you “Adam” by any chance? ”
I am on record on this very site of expressing my anger at the unacceptable violence meted out by thuggish people . This is not the way to stop Israeli brutality …by attacking a female ? Very brave.
However this is a lame and easily ridiculed slur. I stand by my remark above . I keep expecting to come under attack by more intelligent posters … I will keep primed just in case.
May 1, 2010 at 11:00 am
Yohoho
Does keeping primed mean being ready with antisemitic remarks Berchmans, because you feel “driven to it?” Simple question.
And you are a weasel – you should accept this perception of you.
peterthehungarian summed you up wonderfully above at 12.54am.
And I doubt that you are capable of change but I remain in hope.
May 1, 2010 at 11:20 am
Heres to Davy.
Yohoho
“Does keeping primed mean being ready with antisemitic remarks Berchmans, because you feel “driven to it?” Simple question.”
No the question is complex ..it is the poster that is simple. You use such unsubtle and obvious attempts to score points . I will have said something along the lines of being targetted on CIF in the days when folk would be allowed to call people “anti Semitic” …and I will have used language unacceptable to really hardened pro Israelis.
Calling someone “anti Semitic” is a great tactic..it is such a disgusting slur ..there is no real equivalent.. “Islamophobic” lacks the Nazi like connotations. And you can do this again and again whenever your other argument fails…I think I once saw such a phenomenon
May 1, 2010 at 2:04 pm
Yohoho
I am not trying to score points off you Berchmans – that’d really be beneath me because there are far more worthy and intelligent opponents who are at least prepared to argue their corner.
And to call someone like you antisemitic when he/she makes antisemitic remarks (and haven’t the smarts to identify when he/she is being utterly offensive and moreover KEEPS ON DOING IT) has to be fair comment.
I admit I am “phobic” of Islam – I have seen and heard enough from the sort of filth which writes for your friends on CiF (and I have read your comments in support of them) for it to be a realistic position for a Jewish person in the UK at this time.
The sort of antipathy I have towards Islam is based on how Islam behaves towards Jews and other kufar and is very different from the sort of brainless antisemitic filth peddled more and more in al-Grauniad and elsewhere, but I doubt that you’d be able to grasp the that subtle distinction.
You’ve given no indication hitherto that you are capable of it.